The Hamilton Spectator, Canada - 1 July, 2014
By Dean Bee
OTTAWA - Many of the Justice Department's finest legal minds are falling prey to a garden-variety Internet scam.
An internal survey shows almost 2,000 staff were conned into clicking on a phoney "phishing" link in their email, raising questions about the security of sensitive information.
The department launched the mock scam in December as a security exercise, sending emails to 5,000 employees to test their ability to recognize cyber fraud.
The emails looked like genuine communications from government or financial institutions, and contained a link to a fake website that was also made to look like the real thing.
Across the globe, an estimated 156 million of these so-called "phishing" emails are sent daily, and anyone duped into clicking on the embedded web link risks transferring confidential information — such as online banking passwords — to criminals.
The Justice Department's mock exercise caught 1,850 people clicking on the phoney embedded links, or 37 per cent of everyone who received the emails.
That's a much higher rate than for the general population, which a federal website says is only about five per cent.
The exercise did not put any confidential information at risk, but the poor results raise red flags about public servants being caught by actual phishing emails.
A spokeswoman says "no privacy breaches have been reported" from any real phishing scams at Justice Canada.
Carole Saindon also said that two more waves of mock emails in February and April show improved results, with clicking rates falling by half.
"This is an awareness campaign designed to inform and educate employees on issues surrounding cyber security to protect the integrity of the department's information systems and in turn better protect Canadians," she said in an email.
"In this case, this exercise specifically dealt with the threat from phishing which is increasingly being used as an attack vehicle of choice by cyber criminals."
"As this project progresses, we are pleased that the effectiveness of this campaign is showing significant improvement."
A February briefing note on the exercise was obtained by The Canadian Press under the Access to Information Act.
The document indicates there are more such exercises planned — in June, August and October — and that the simulations will be "graduating in levels of sophistication."
Those caught by the simulation are notified by a pop-up window, giving them tips on spotting malicious messages.
The federal government's Get Cyber Safe website says about 10 per cent of the 156 million phishing emails globally make it through spam filters each day.
Of those, some eight million are actually opened by the recipient, but only 800,000 click on the links — or about five per cent of those who received the emails.
About 10 per cent of those opening the link are fooled into providing confidential information — which represents a worldwide haul of 80,000 credit-card numbers, bank accounts, passwords and other confidential information every day.
"Don't get phished!," says the federal website, "Phishing emails often look like real emails from a trusted source such as your bank or an online retailer, right down to logos and graphics."
The site says more than one million Canadians have entered personal banking details on a site they don't know, based on surveys.
In late 2012, Justice Canada was embroiled in a major privacy breach when one of its lawyers working at Human Resources and Skills Development Canada was involved in the loss of a USB key.
The key contained unencrypted confidential information about 5,045 Canadians who had appealed disability rulings under the Canada Pension Plan, including their medical condition and SIN numbers. The privacy commissioner is still investigating the breach.
The department has some 5,000 employees, about half of them lawyers.
The Canadian Press